Friday, March 02, 2007
A Liberal Hawk Recants (Part One)
Armed Liberal at Winds of Change links to two self-confessions of former Iraq War supporters, who now wish to publicly recant in fits of self-flagellation. The problem is, they do a lot more striking of others than they do themselves.
Peter Beinart grovels under the moral glare of his wife – so he claims – as he confesses at The New Republic, and Norwegian “Warblogger” Bjorn Staerk grovels at the altar of ambiguity. (Must be some kind of Scandinavian existentialist thing.)
I suppose that’s what “formerly” pro-War Liberals have to do. They are thoroughly on the outs with the new Majorities in Congress, their own Party, and what they think must be the entirety of the American people. Following the example of their First Family, they follow the whim of the majority, and jettison ideals or principles.
I say, good riddance to bad faith. Like most everything else in the Progressive Handbook, their short-lived geopolitical idealism was entirely dependent on the extreme perfection of Everything Going Just Great Without Any Complications. Like Nationalized Healthcare, one might add, or other Socialist prescriptions for public policy. Shake the dust off your sandals when you leave their house.
Though I count Beinart the more dishonest of the two based on their self-confessions, I don’t know Staerk at all. Beinart I’ve read previously. Call that a disclaimer if you want, but given the nature of public self-confession, I consider the confessions themselves to be sufficient context for critique. (Isn’t that their intent? Beyond a fond reminiscence for those heart-warming relics of Communism, Public Self Confessions.)
Don’t get me wrong, I’m sure Beinart is truly remorseful for surrendering his elevated jadedness for a zeal for democratic idealism, as reflected in the way he says the phrase “If the
Beinart then offers the sop of the liberation of Kuwait and our UN peacekeeping interventions in Bosnia and Kosovo in the transition between his first (and should have been forever) love for suspicion of all thing US inspired, and the siren’s song for military intervention in the service of progressive ideals.
Beinart met Kanan Makiya, an Iraqi exile and chronicler of the abuses of Saddam Hussein. Makiya saw an invasion as a chance to end the horror of Saddam:
That's why Makiya insisted that an
I don’t know how hard Beinart tried to follow up with him, but Beinart says “But I haven't seen him, or read anything he's said or written, in several years. He's living, and suffering, with the consequences of this war, I suppose. And so are we.”
I wonder at how Kanan Makiya feels about playing Siren to Beinart’s sailor. Maybe he’s suffering, I don’t know, but probably less than Beinart suffers from estrangement with his natural allies. Pity the reformed Warblogger, almost as pitiful as the deranged but still evil Neocons.
Feh. I suspect this is a bit of over-wrought hyperbole to get him back into the good graces of the Dominant Democratic Wing of the Democratic Party (others might have different labels for same). If this really reflects Beinart’s thought process, his intellect is weaker and his psychology more unbalanced than I would have believed.
Why do Liberals and leftists of any stripe so loath the foundations of the oldest and freest Democracy in the world? We set afire the hopes and aspirations of oppressed people the world over? Those fortunate enough to achieve American style liberty -- as opposed to Communist, Socialist, or Demagogic imposters – risk their lives and everything they own to attain or to retain that liberty.
Cynics like the Beinart of old, and his former and future colleagues, view any sin of commission or omission by the
I can’t explain why some erstwhile Leftists for a time backed their Grand Experiment in
Then there’s this:
I was willing to gamble, too--partly, I suppose, because, in the era of the all-volunteer military, I wasn't gambling with my own life. And partly because I didn't think I was gambling many of my countrymen's. I had come of age in that surreal period between
News flash to Beinart: you’re not gambling with anybody’s life, one, they’re not yours, and two, you are a writer, not a decision-maker, and not a particularly influential one at that. And I don’t believe for a second that you ruminated more than moments upon
Perhaps through some rebellious or contrarian streak, you thought that the Powers of Oppression could be turned this one time in service to the Oppressed. That I’d believe.
You say you were “intoxicated,” that you couldn’t find an answer to a question posed by Salmon Rushdie: “Will the American and European left make the mistake of being so eager to oppose Bush that they end up seeming to back Saddam Hussein?”
You say you have an answer now (emphasis mine):
But there was an answer, and it was the one I heard from that South African many years ago. It begins with a painful realization about the
We lack the wisdom and virtue. Quite in contrast to the Europeans or the UN, no doubt. I wish Beinart would point to an example of a “liberal international order” that is successful at restraining the use of force, and achieving a result that is in fact desirable. I see an awful lot of pretenders out there, and a whole lot of force being restrained – especially European, Asian, and other military forces in defense of their own security, in favor of the
What “fellow democracies” opposed the fight against communism, whether the occasion of the war in
What a slander to suggest that those who support the war in
And on last retort to Beinart. The Iraqis didn’t “trust the
There’s a different answer available to Beinart, to Liberals, in answer to Rushdie’s question. “Yes. We hate George Bush that much. We don’t much care which side of justice, or democracy, or national interest, or world security that puts us on.”
Oh, that’s not what you read here, but remember that most of the same voices who speak out against this war would be silent if the President who waged it was Democrat, as they have in all previous instances. That’s why you hear so many good things about
Links to this post:
Subscribe to Posts [Atom]