Friday, March 03, 2006
The AP Misreports Again!
The Associated Press continues to factually misreport (as in report untruths) of the recently released video tapes. Today’s story now includes mention of Gov. Blanco saying that levees had not been breached), but in rehashing yesterday’s non-factual but no doubt accurate report, the AP story includes the following:
The new video came to light a day after the AP obtained footage of an Aug. 28 briefing — the day before Katrina hit — that showed officials warning the storm might breach levees, put lives at risk in the Superdome and overwhelm rescuers. Bush and Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff were among those on the videotaped call.
Given that, in the latest tape, Gov. Blanco conflates both the “overtopping” and “breaching” of levees, I guess it should not be surprising that the AP reporters don’t realize these don’t mean the same thing, and the hydro-engineering implications of both terms are dramatically different.
For those still fact challenged, “overtopping” means water comes over the top of a levee. The levee is still structurally sound, intact, and will continue to hold back the much greater magnitude of water that remains behind the levee that that amount that comes over. It also means, after the surge, no more water comes in.
“Breaching” means that the levee collapses or there is a break, which, when a levee is already holding back a maximum amount of water, generally would lead to a catastrophic collapse. In this scenario, and hugely greater volume of water comes through the levee, and keeps coming through, until the water level would fall below the base of the levee (the surrounding ground elevation) or there is no more water. Given that we’re talking the Gulf of Mexico, and
The AP includes this gem as well:
Senate Democratic leader Harry Reid of
In this case, the only people systematically misleading the American people are the AP and other media reporters distorting facts, and the crass political opportunists who gladly and knowingly repeat untruths.
Links: Wizbang, Basil's Blog, bRight & Early, Cao's Blog, Jo's Cafe, Mudville Gazette, RightWingNation
Niether failure will be a simple fix as overtopping will require levees to be rebuilt. Breaching is mostly caused by poor design and or material usage, again a comprehensive rebuild is the only solution.
Dave
Again, however, what was warned of was that the storm surge would exceed the height of the levees, not that the levees themselves would breach.
The one can clearly lead to the other, but not immediately, and not necessarily. And that was not was was being briefed, nor warned of. That is precisely the point for those who would imagine hindsight being 20/20 (only as it can be applied in a negative way against the Bush Administration).
Why did waters overtop the levees for the extended amount of time it took for selected occasions of overtopping to cause levee failure? More errors of long term design -- the levee system itself -- than by the stormwaters. And that's not what this debate is focusing on. Read the Popular Mechanics report, it is the most authoritative.
CPT Kevin,
You sir are too clever by half.
Antagonists create media storms over anything that can make Bush look bad, and in the process distort, take out of context, misrepresent, and rewrite actual history.
Then when they're called on it, critics like you equate the criticism to the proven-by-felony conviction of Bill Clinton, using a Pynthonesque parsing of simple language to make black white and white black.
It depends on what "is" is indeed.
It depends on nothing other than how bad you want the Bush Administration to look. Nothing more, or less.
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
Links to this post:
<< Home
Subscribe to Posts [Atom]




